“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.”
Introduction
There’s something timeless about the music of Hank Williams. It’s the kind of music that echoes through generations, carrying with it stories of heartache, love, and the human experience. One such song that resonates deeply is “Why Should We Try Anymore.” Released during a time when country music was the voice of the common folk, this song encapsulates the pain of a relationship on the brink of collapse—a theme that is as relevant today as it was when it first hit the airwaves.
About The Composition
- Title: Why Should We Try Anymore
- Composer: Hank Williams
- Premiere Date: May 1950
- Album/Opus/Collection: Single Release (1950)
- Genre: Country
Background
“Why Should We Try Anymore” was released in May 1950, a period when Hank Williams was at the height of his career. This song stands as a poignant reflection of Williams’ ability to tap into the raw emotions of life, particularly the struggles within a relationship. Written by Williams himself, the song explores the depths of despair and resignation in a failing marriage, themes that were drawn from his personal life and turbulent relationship with his wife, Audrey.
The song was recorded at Castle Studio in Nashville, Tennessee, a place that saw the birth of many of Hank Williams’ classic hits. Upon its release, the song resonated with many listeners, climbing the charts and solidifying Williams’ reputation as one of country music’s most influential voices.
Musical Style
“Why Should We Try Anymore” is a quintessential country song, featuring the straightforward, yet emotionally charged lyrics that Williams was known for. The instrumentation is simple, yet effective, with the steel guitar, fiddle, and Williams’ plaintive voice driving the song’s narrative. The melody is haunting, reflecting the somber tone of the lyrics, and the structure is typical of the honky-tonk style—verse, chorus, and a bridge that underscores the song’s emotional climax. The song’s simplicity allows the raw emotion in Williams’ voice to shine through, making it a powerful piece of music that speaks directly to the listener’s heart.
Lyrics/Libretto
The lyrics of “Why Should We Try Anymore” are a heartbreaking exploration of a relationship that has run its course. Williams’ use of straightforward language makes the song relatable, while the repetition of the question “Why should we try anymore?” drives home the sense of hopelessness and futility. The song tells the story of a couple who have exhausted their efforts to save their marriage, and now face the reality that they have nothing left to fight for. It’s a poignant reflection on the emotional toll of a relationship that’s beyond repair.
Performance History
Since its release, “Why Should We Try Anymore” has been performed by various artists, but it’s Hank Williams’ original recording that remains the definitive version. Over the years, the song has been covered by artists who admire Williams’ ability to convey deep emotion with simplicity. Despite the numerous covers, Williams’ version is often lauded for its authenticity and emotional depth.
Cultural Impact
“Why Should We Try Anymore” is more than just a country song—it’s a reflection of the struggles that many face in their personal lives. Its themes of heartbreak and resignation are universal, making it a song that resonates with audiences beyond the country music sphere. The song has been featured in various media and continues to be a staple in country music collections, influencing countless artists who followed in Williams’ footsteps.
Legacy
Hank Williams’ “Why Should We Try Anymore” continues to be a significant piece of country music history. It’s a song that encapsulates the emotional depth that Williams brought to his music, and its relevance endures as long as people experience the heartbreak of failed relationships. The song remains a testament to Williams’ legacy as one of country music’s most profound and influential artists.
Conclusion
“Why Should We Try Anymore” is a song that speaks to the heart, reflecting the pain and resignation that comes with the end of a relationship. Hank Williams’ ability to capture these emotions in his music is what makes this song, and his entire body of work, so enduring. For those who haven’t yet experienced the raw emotion of this piece, I highly recommend seeking out Williams’ original recording. It’s a powerful reminder of why Hank Williams remains a towering figure in the world of country music.
Video
Lyrics
What’s the use to deny? We’ve been living a lie
That we should have admitted before
We were just victims of a half-hearted love
So why should we try any more?
The vows that we make are only to break
We drift like a wave from the shore
The kisses we steal we know are not real
So why should we try any more?
The dreams that we knew can never come true
They’re gone to return no more
False love like ours fades with the flowers
So why should we try any more?
Our story’s so old, again has been told
On the past, let’s close the door
And smile, don’t regret but live and forget
There’s no use to try any more